What actually happened with The Idol on HBO?

Started 2 months ago by Johnny_4Real in General Discussions

Hey everyone! So, I finally got around to watching ‘The Idol,’ the HBO series co-created by The Weeknd. Given all the buzz and controversy, I was curious. Hone...

Body

Hey everyone! So, I finally got around to watching ‘The Idol,’ the HBO series co-created by The Weeknd. Given all the buzz and controversy, I was curious. Honestly, I found it… underwhelming. What are your thoughts?

9 Replies

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report

    I watched it when it first aired. The concept had potential, especially with The Weeknd and Lily-Rose Depp leading. But the e*******n? Not so much. The plot felt disjointed, and some scenes seemed provocative just for the sake of it

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report
    I watched it when it first aired. The concept had potential, especially with The Weeknd and Lily-Rose Depp leading. But the e*******n? Not so much. The plot felt disjointed, and some scenes seemed provocative just for the sake of it

    Agreed. I remember reading that the show faced criticism for its explicit content and was even canceled after one season.

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report

    It’s interesting how ‘The Idol’ tried to delve into the dark side of the music industry. But instead of offering insightful commentary, it felt more like a shallow portrayal filled with cliches.

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report
    It’s interesting how ‘The Idol’ tried to delve into the dark side of the music industry. But instead of offering insightful commentary, it felt more like a shallow portrayal filled with cliches.

    Exactly! And considering The Weeknd’s deep involvement, I expected a more authentic depiction.

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report

    I read that The Weeknd acknowledged the criticism and mentioned that the story “could have been told in a different way”

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report

    I tried watching the first episode but couldn’t get through it. The pacing was off, and it didn’t hold my attention.

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report

    I pushed through the entire season, hoping it would improve. Sadly, it didn’t. It’s rare for me to say this, but I was relieved when HBO announced its cancellation.

  • Replied 2 months ago

    Report

    It’s a shame because the cast had talent. Lily-Rose Depp defended the show’s creator, Sam Levinson, despite the backlash.

  • Replied 1 month ago

    Report

    True. And while it’s commendable that she stood by the project, it doesn’t change the fact that many viewers found the content problematic.