What actually happened with The Idol on HBO?

Started 10 months ago by Johnny_4Real in General Discussions

Hey everyone! So, I finally got around to watching ‘The Idol,’ the HBO series co-created by The Weeknd. Given all the buzz and controversy, I was curious. Hone...

Body

Hey everyone! So, I finally got around to watching ‘The Idol,’ the HBO series co-created by The Weeknd. Given all the buzz and controversy, I was curious. Honestly, I found it… underwhelming. What are your thoughts?

9 Replies

  • Replied 10 months ago

    Report

    I watched it when it first aired. The concept had potential, especially with The Weeknd and Lily-Rose Depp leading. But the e*******n? Not so much. The plot felt disjointed, and some scenes seemed provocative just for the sake of it

  • Replied 10 months ago

    Report
    I watched it when it first aired. The concept had potential, especially with The Weeknd and Lily-Rose Depp leading. But the e*******n? Not so much. The plot felt disjointed, and some scenes seemed provocative just for the sake of it

    Agreed. I remember reading that the show faced criticism for its explicit content and was even canceled after one season.

  • Replied 10 months ago

    Report

    It’s interesting how ‘The Idol’ tried to delve into the dark side of the music industry. But instead of offering insightful commentary, it felt more like a shallow portrayal filled with cliches.

  • Replied 9 months ago

    Report
    It’s interesting how ‘The Idol’ tried to delve into the dark side of the music industry. But instead of offering insightful commentary, it felt more like a shallow portrayal filled with cliches.

    Exactly! And considering The Weeknd’s deep involvement, I expected a more authentic depiction.

  • Replied 9 months ago

    Report

    I read that The Weeknd acknowledged the criticism and mentioned that the story “could have been told in a different way”

  • Replied 9 months ago

    Report

    I tried watching the first episode but couldn’t get through it. The pacing was off, and it didn’t hold my attention.

  • Replied 9 months ago

    Report

    I pushed through the entire season, hoping it would improve. Sadly, it didn’t. It’s rare for me to say this, but I was relieved when HBO announced its cancellation.

  • Replied 9 months ago

    Report

    It’s a shame because the cast had talent. Lily-Rose Depp defended the show’s creator, Sam Levinson, despite the backlash.

  • Replied 9 months ago

    Report

    True. And while it’s commendable that she stood by the project, it doesn’t change the fact that many viewers found the content problematic.